What Holds Women Back from Leadership in Indonesian Factories?

Women make up most of the workforce in many Indonesian garment and footwear factories. In the four factories studied by Innovision for the International Finance Corporation, the share of women among workers ranged from 51% to 85%. Yet the higher you look in the hierarchy, the fewer women there are. The scoping study asked why. It was designed to inform an accelerator programme to help women move into leadership in factories that supply a global apparel brand. The team engaged 112 people in four factories: 100 workers, including operators, line leaders and supervisors, and 12 members of senior management. The national picture sets the context. Women comprise 48% of entry-level formal professions in Indonesia, but only 13% of senior management positions, 5% of board members and 2% of CEOs. Female labour force participation is around 52% and has been stagnant for two decades, with a gap of about 30 percentage points compared with men. The factories studied are not indifferent. All four had taken steps. Training capacity was strong in some, with one factory sharing a list of 75 trainings and another running 119 internal training programmes. Some offered leadership programmes, mentorship, and promotion based on screening for performance and potential. Others had targets, such as 26% women in junior management by 2025 and 25% women among leaders. Support for pregnant workers and lactating mothers was in place in some. And yet the study found that there were fewer women in leadership despite these affirmative actions. Managers recognised the gap. As one HR lead put it, it is crucial to make women more courageous in taking leadership positions, because they are capable leaders. The study looked at the systemic barriers that contribute: corporate, societal, cultural and economic. It examined which soft skills could help close the gap, how women's experiences differ at each step of the career ladder, and what policies factories have for advancing women. The lesson is that policy on paper is not enough. Training open to everyone does not by itself produce more women supervisors and managers. Targeted support, role models, mentoring and attention to the points where women drop off the ladder all matter. The accelerator that followed was built to respond to these findings.